Monday, September 3, 2012

"He's Gone!"

In last night’s episode of “Breaking Bad,” Walter White (“WW”)  and Jesse Pinkman (“JP”) discuss the whereabouts of “Mike”- the muscle for the late Gus Fring’s meth distribution operation, and recent partner of WW’s and JP’s reconstituted operation.  Mike is about to be arrested by the DEA and is fleeing.  WW agrees to retrieve Mike’s drop bag - a bag containing a pistol and a large amount of cash - and bring it to Mike so that he can escape.

Their meeting did not go well.  It ended with WW killing Mike for nothing more than showing flagrant disrespect.  This, by the way, is new.  All prior killing by WW and JP was genuinely necessary for their own survival.  Here, WW kills because Mike refuses to respect him as the great man that he has become.

Thus Spoke Zarathustra, anyone?

But I digress.  When WW returns to their meth lab headquarters, JP asks him what happened?  He asks, “did you get the money to Mike?  WW responded “Yes.”  JP then asks “did he get away?”  To this WW responded “he’s gone.” 

“He’s gone?”  Well, that’s certainly correct.  Mike’s corpse may have been in the trunk of the car that WW and JP were standing next to, but he was definitely “gone.”  Still, everyone can see that WW was lying to JP.  He combined JP’s knowledge of what Mike intended to do, with a technically true but intentionally misleading response, to lead JP to believe something that WW knew was false.  It was a great moment of irony - made so by the obviousness of the lie.

What interests me is how partisans can sincerely deny equally obvious instances of this type of lie in Politics?  Take, for example, the Republican’s (now campaign foundational) claim that Obama said “you didn’t build that.”  Its certainly correct to note that Obama said that - he uttered those exact words.  But the context in which Obama uttered those words makes it unmistakably clear that he said that successful business people did not build the infrastructure and “amazing American system” that allowed their business to succeed.

Yet Republicans keep claiming, with a straight face, that Obama said successful people did not build their businesses - the government did.  Hence the constant refrain “we built it!”

This is an obvious lie - so obvious that it is hard to believe it would get any traction at all.  But it has. What’s obviously a lie between WW and JP is undeniably and irrefutably true when it comes from the mouth of Mitt Romney.

That’s psychologically remarkable!

Any thoughts?

Joe H.

5 comments:

Chris Daida said...

AAAAAGH!!!! YOU'RE SUPPOSED TO SAY "SPOILER ALERT!" grrrrr. :P

Chris Daida said...

The wingnuts also say Obama is a socialist. But they rarely ever know what socialism really is.

Here's what it really boils down to, in the vast majority of cases: Falsehoods, spoken by social conservatives, are not false. They are truths covered up by the debauched liberal media. They are bits of special knowledge accessible only to the faithful. You don't understand, because you don't believe.

Joe Huster said...

Sorry about the lack of a Spoiler Alert.

As to you analysis Chris, There's a lot to it, but I don't think this kind of thinking is widespread. Only true believers.

Chris Daida said...

Do the true believers not seem widespread to you? People like Sean Faircloth, author of Attack of the Theocrats, seem to think the problem is huge and getting worse. I think I agree with him.

Btw, as I suspected they would, evangelicals are siding with Romney.

Chris Daida said...

Sorry. I just realized I forgot to put quotes around my "You don't understand. . ." line above. I didn't mean you, specifically.